This ethereal, lighter-styled 2009 (no doubt because of the high Cabernet Franc content) is somewhat difficult to fully evaluate at this stage, but it exhibits beautifully sweet, pure, blue and red fruits (raspberries) in a medium-bodied format. The wine is sublime in its softness, finesse, and delicacy. It should put on weight and perform even better in a year or two, and should drink nicely for 15+ years. Tasted three times. 90-92 points

Tasted at the Graves UGC. This has a very upfront nose with black, slightly gamey fruit that nods towards the Rhone, but there is also very fine definition and purity, a sense of exuberance to this Les Carmes. The palate is full-bodied with slightly grainy tannins, that gamey quality coming through on the entry, lovely structure, smoky black fruits, cooked meat, a touch of sage towards the finish. Real character to this 2009 Les Carmes. Superb. Tasted April 2010. 92-94 points

Showing a beautiful intense deep color and a fruity, ripe yet discreet nose. This wine`s expression on entry is more mellow than usual. The wine then develops over a medium aromatic intensity and a tender body, without displaying its usual sappy character. A little flavour comes back on finish. A medium length. Even if this wine performs with coated tannins, the aromatic signature that has for ever defined the estate is not to be found this year. It is structured as a Saint-Emilion. Tasted three times with consistent results. 87 points

Dense purple red, concentrated and rather earthy blackcurrant nose, good broad fruit with warmth and vigour, natural tannins and acidity need to blend in with the fleshy charm and depth. Drink 2015-25. 17 points