Inky in colour, roses, slate, liquorice, cassis bud, this is slim but with grip and texture, lifts through the palate and is an enjoyable if understated wine. 50% new oak. Harvest 1 to 15 October, Lea Zuger owner. 91 points

The 2024 Malescot Saint Exupery is a bit brawny and rough around the edges at this early stage. Elevage will play a determinant role here. There`s good energy, but the 2024 is also edgy in its contours and fragile in its balance today. 88-91 points

The 2024 Malescot Saint Exupery has a cohesive nose with ample scents of blackberry, raspberry, light violet and just a touch of cedar in the background—backward, for sure, but it unfurls in the glass. The medium-bodied palate has firm tannins, a little chewy in a pleasant way with composure and bite on the finish. This is a thoroughly enjoyable fresh Margaux that will drink earlier than the 2022. 91-93 points