Tannins are grippy on the opening, cutting into the raspberry and red cherry fruit. Grilled coffee bean notes and campfire smoke add depth through the mid palate but this is a challenging vintage for such a consistent and impressive wine. 3.6 pH. Harvest 19 September to 8 October. 40 hl/ha. 30% new oak for ageing. 89 points

The 2024 Carbonnieux is floral and aromatic but also very light, with only modest structure and complexity. 86-88 points

The 2024 Carbonnieux has a light nose with brambly red fruit, mocha and earthy tones. It is calling out for a bit more vigor, but it is clean and shows no signs of greenness. The palate is medium-bodied with pliant tannins and gentle grip. This Carbonnieux works because it has not been pushed too hard. Though it`s short, this retains balance and focus. Fine. 89-91 points