The 2015 Haut Bages Liberal is a blend of 65% Cabernet Sauvignon and 35% Merlot that is matured in 40% new French oak over a 16-month period. It has a slightly chalky bouquet, tight-knit and conservative, but that is the usual style of this Pauillac cru en barriques. The palate is medium-bodied with solid tannin. This is an edgy Pauillac that is nicely focused, although I would have liked to have seen more substance towards the finish to balance the slightly obdurate tannins. This was one Pauillac cru that feels challenged by the September storms. 88-90 points

Slightly lean and leafy fruit, but this wine is never on the plummy side. It already shows finesse and grip and will gain weight. 90 points

The tannins are a little firm at the moment, but this is only an eight month old Pauillac after all. There’s plenty of stuffing behind the wood: plum, blackberry and cassis with some liquorice and wood smoke. Drink: 2022-28. 91 points

The 2015 Haut-Bages Libe ral is finessed, precise and persistent, with lovely overall balance and class. This is a decidedly laid-back wine for the vintage, yet all the elements are in the right place. The dark cherry and plum flavors are quite attractive. This is a nicely done and promising Pauillac, even if the tannins could use a bit more polish. 90-93 points